
Enjoy fast, free delivery, exclusive deals, and award-winning movies & TV shows with Prime
Try Prime
and start saving today with fast, free delivery
Amazon Prime includes:
Fast, FREE Delivery is available to Prime members. To join, select "Try Amazon Prime and start saving today with Fast, FREE Delivery" below the Add to Cart button.
Amazon Prime members enjoy:- Cardmembers earn 5% Back at Amazon.com with a Prime Credit Card.
- Unlimited Free Two-Day Delivery
- Streaming of thousands of movies and TV shows with limited ads on Prime Video.
- A Kindle book to borrow for free each month - with no due dates
- Listen to over 2 million songs and hundreds of playlists
- Unlimited photo storage with anywhere access
Important: Your credit card will NOT be charged when you start your free trial or if you cancel during the trial period. If you're happy with Amazon Prime, do nothing. At the end of the free trial, your membership will automatically upgrade to a monthly membership.
Buy new:
-45% $10.99$10.99
Ships from: Amazon.com Sold by: Amazon.com
Save with Used - Good
$9.00$9.00
Ships from: Amazon Sold by: RNA TRADE LLC

Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Follow the authors
OK
We Are Soldiers Still: A Journey Back to the Battlefields of Vietnam Paperback – Illustrated, July 28, 2009
Purchase options and add-ons
“Powerful. . . . A candid, highly informative, and heartfelt tale of forgiveness between former fierce enemies in the Vietnam War.” —St. Petersburg Times
The #1 New York Times bestseller We Were Soldiers Once . . . and Young brought to life one of the most pivotal and heartbreaking battles of the Vietnam War. In this powerful sequel, Lt. Gen Harold G. Moore and Joseph L. Galloway bring us up to date on the cadre of soldiers introduced in their first memoir.
Returning to Vietnam’s Ia Drang Valley more than four decades after the battle, Moore and Galloway renew their relationships with ten American veterans of the fabled conflict—and with former adversaries—exploring how the war changed them all, as well as their two countries. We Are Soldiers Still is an emotional journey back to hallowed ground, putting a human face on warfare as the authors reflect on war’s devastating cost. The book includes an Introduction by Gen H. Norman Schwarzkopf.
- Print length288 pages
- LanguageEnglish
- Publication dateJuly 28, 2009
- Dimensions5.31 x 0.65 x 8 inches
- ISBN-10006114777X
- ISBN-13978-0061147777
Book recommendations, author interviews, editors' picks, and more. Read it now
Frequently bought together

Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Editorial Reviews
Review
“It would be a monumental task for Moore and Galloway to top their classic 1992 memoir, We Were Soldiers Once...and Young. But they come close in this sterling sequel...This book proves again that Moore is an exceptionally thoughtful, compassionate and courageous leader and a strong voice for reconciliation and for honoring the men with whom he served.” — Publishers Weekly(starred review)
“An emotional follow-up to military lifer Moore and reporter Galloway’s intense 1992 telling of the Vietnam War’s first major battle between American and North Vietnamese troops. This time, the two, along with other American survivors of the fight, revisit the Ia Drang valley, scene of the bloody 1965 battle—accompanied by the Communist commanders and soldiers who were trying to kill them.” — New York Post
“A worthy and wise successor to one of the best books ever about combat in Vietnam.” — Kirkus Reviews
“We Are Soldiers Still tells the recent story of how Moore and Galloway organized meetings with the Vietnamese commanders they’d fought against so fiercely. . . . There is honor and a measure of military glory in the retelling and in the reunion.” — Christian Science Monitor
“Bookstores are filled with rows of books on leadership and management, but We Are Soldiers Still stands over the rest. Words like riveting and compelling hardly do the book justice...Moore’s reflections on leadership alone make this book worth its purchase price...Moore and Galloway’s latest volume is a moving tribute to the American soldier.” — Army magazine
"A moving testimonial. . . .The memoir poignantly addresses the blindness of war and the compensatory urgings of the heart to be human." — Rocky Mountain News
From the Back Cover
Lt. Gen. Harold Moore and Joseph Galloway return to Vietnam's Ia Drang Valley more than four decades after the battle they recalled in their #1 New York Times bestseller We Were Soldiers Once . . . and Young. Renewing their relationships with ten American veterans of the fabled conflict—and with former adversaries—the authors explore how the war changed them all, as well as their two countries.
We Are Soldiers Still is an emotional journey back to hallowed ground, putting a human face on warfare as the authors reflect on war's devastating cost.
About the Author
Lt. Gen. Harold G. Moore (USA Ret.) graduated from West Point, commanded two infantry companies in the Korean War, and was a battalion and brigade commander in Vietnam. After thirty-two years of service, he retired from the Army in 1977.
Recently retired senior military correspondent for Knight Ridder Newspapers Joseph L. Galloway served as a special consultant to Gen. Colin Powell at the State Department in 2001 and 2002, and spent more than forty years as an editor and writer for UPI and U.S. News & World Report.
Product details
- Publisher : Harper Perennial
- Publication date : July 28, 2009
- Edition : Reprint
- Language : English
- Print length : 288 pages
- ISBN-10 : 006114777X
- ISBN-13 : 978-0061147777
- Item Weight : 10.4 ounces
- Dimensions : 5.31 x 0.65 x 8 inches
- Best Sellers Rank: #119,604 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- Customer Reviews:
About the authors
Legendary combat leader and New York Times Bestselling author, Lieutenant General Harold (Hal) Gregory Moore Jr, passed away peacefully at age 94 on February 10, 2017.
Hal was born on February 13, 1922, in Bardstown KY to Harold and Mary (Crume) Moore. Hal started a 32-year military career upon entry into the United States Military Academy in 1942, convincing a Congressman from Georgia to swap Hal’s Kentucky appointment to the Naval Academy for one to West Point. Upon graduation in 1945, he served on occupation duty in Japan; he returned to Fort Bragg where he met and married the great love of his life, Julie Compton. He tested parachutes, surviving multiple malfunctions to include being hung up and towed behind a plane. Deployed to the Korean War in 1952, he commanded an Infantry rifle and heavy mortar company in the 7th Infantry Division and was awarded two Bronze Star Medals for Valor.
Subsequent assignments included teaching tactics at West Point, developing airborne and air assault equipment in the Pentagon, and a tour of duty in Norway where he planned the ground defense of northern Germany, Denmark, and Scandinavia. Upon completion of the course of study at the Naval War College, Hal took command of the 2nd Battalion, 23rd Infantry at Fort Benning, GA. Fourteen months later, the unit was designated the 1st Battalion, 7th Cavalry (Custer’s old outfit) and deployed to Vietnam with the 1st Cavalry Division in 1965.
Hal is best known for his leadership in the first major battle between the US and the People’s Army of Vietnam (PAVN) that occurred in the remote Ia Drang Valley of the Central Highlands in November 1965. Within 20 minutes of the first shot, the 7th Cavalry, vastly outnumbered, was assaulted by hundreds of enemy furiously determined to over-run it. After a three-day bloodbath, the enemy quit the field leaving over six hundred of their dead littering the battleground. Hal was awarded the Distinguished Service Cross, the nation’s second-highest award for valor, for his actions during the fight. Hal then assumed command of the 3rd Brigade of the 1st Cavalry Division and led it through several major campaigns in 1966 earning another Bronze Star Medal for Valor for carrying wounded to safety under “withering small and automatic weapons fire.”
In 1968, Hal pinned on his first star and led the planning for the Army’s withdrawal from Vietnam. He returned to Korea in 1969 and was promoted to Major General and given command of the 7th Infantry Division to “straighten out that Division” after it was fractured with insubordination and riots. Over the next year, Hal rebuilt the Division back into an effective fighting force. In 1971, he took command of the Training Center and Fort Ord, CA in the era of the Vietnam antiwar demonstrations, associated drug problems, continuing racial tensions and the transition to the “modern volunteer Army.” He applied lessons learned from the 7th Infantry to create another successful outcome. In 1974, Hal was promoted to Lieutenant General and assigned to the Pentagon as the Deputy Chief of Staff for Personnel for the Army where he was most proud of actions he took to rebuild an NCO Corps almost destroyed by the Vietnam War.
Following retirement from active duty in 1977, he worked as the Executive Vice President of the Crested Butte Mountain Resort in Colorado. In 1981, working with his co-author, Joe Galloway, he turned his attention to the research that underpinned their 1992 New York Times Bestselling book on the Ia Drang battles, We Were Soldiers Once… and Young. In 2002, the book was the basis of the acclaimed movie, We Were Soldiers, where Mel Gibson portrayed Hal. After being devastated by the loss of his wife, Julie, in 2004, Hal withdrew from public life but worked with Joe Galloway to produce the 2008 sequel to the first book; We are Soldiers Still: A Journey Back to the Battlefields of Vietnam.
Hal was a dedicated outdoorsman who loved to ski, hike, camp, and fish and was most proud of the fact that he “infected” all his children with the same passion. Hal was fishing in a local bass fishing tournament in 1952 on the morning his son, Steve was born. He always claimed he had permission to go - something Julie disputed. The fact that Hal won a nice Shakespeare reel did nothing to mitigate the trouble he was in upon his return.
Hal was known for his finely tuned sense of humor; earning the nickname of “Captain Fun” from his grandchildren. He would routinely send funny postcards of “jackalopes” and hide small toys around the house in anticipation of visits.
Joseph L. Galloway, one of America’s premier war and foreign correspondents for half a century, recently retired as the senior military correspondent for Knight Ridder Newspapers. Before that he held an assignment as a special consultant to General Colin Powell at the State Department.
He is the co-author of the 2020 book They Were Soldiers: The Sacrifices and Contributions of Our Vietnam Veterans with Marvin J. Wolf, published by Nelson Books. They Were Soldiers features 49 interviews with Vietnam Veterans from all walks of life and focuses on the contributions they made to America after they returned home. It makes a strong case that the men and women who participated in the Vietnam War were every bit the equal to their “Greatest Generation” parents—and that they were certainly the greatest of their generation.
Early in 2013, Galloway was sworn into service as a special consultant to the Vietnam War 50th Anniversary Commemoration project run by the Office of the Secretary of Defense. He was also a permanent consultant to Ken Burns’ Florentine Films project to make a documentary history of the Vietnam War which was initially broadcast in 2017 on PBS.
Galloway, a native of Refugio, Texas, spent 22 years as a foreign and war correspondent and bureau chief for United Press International, and 20 years as a senior editor and senior writer for U.S. News & World Report magazine. He joined Knight Ridder in the fall of 2002.
During the course of 15 years of foreign postings—including assignments in Japan, Indonesia, India, Singapore and three years as UPI bureau chief in Moscow in the former Soviet Union—Galloway served four tours as a war correspondent in Vietnam and also covered the 1971 India-Pakistan War and half a dozen other combat operations.
In 1990-1991 Galloway covered Desert Shield/Desert Storm, riding with the 24th Infantry Division (Mech) in the assault into Iraq. Galloway also covered the Haiti incursion and made trips to Iraq to cover the war there in 2003 and 2005-2006.
The late Gen. H. Norman Schwarzkopf, who first met Galloway in South Vietnam when he was a brand new Army major, called the Texan “the finest combat correspondent of our generation—a soldier’s reporter and a soldier’s friend.”
He is co-author, with the late Lt. Gen. Hal Moore, of the New York Times and national bestseller We Were Soldiers Once…And Young (published by Random House), which was made into the critically acclaimed movie, “We Were Soldiers” starring Mel Gibson. We Were Soldiers Once…And Young is presently in print in six different languages with more than 1.2 million copies sold.
Galloway also co-authored Triumph Without Victory: The History of the Persian Gulf War for Times Books—and in 2008 he and Gen. Moore published their sequel to We Were Soldiers for HarperCollins, the New York Times bestseller We Are Soldiers Still: A Journey Back to the Battlefields of Vietnam.
When Military History magazine polled 50 leading historians to choose the Ten Greatest Books Ever Written on War, We Were Soldiers Once…and Young was among those ten books.
On May 1, 1998, Galloway was decorated with a Bronze Star Medal with V for Valor for rescuing wounded soldiers under fire in the Ia Drang Valley in November 1965. His is the only medal of valor the U.S. Army awarded to a civilian for actions in combat during the entire Vietnam War.
Galloway received the National Magazine Award in 1991 for a U.S. News cover article on the 25th anniversary of the Ia Drang Battles, and the National News Media Award of the U.S. Veterans of Foreign Wars in 1992 for coverage of the Gulf War. In 2000, he received the President’s Award for the Arts of the Vietnam Veterans Association of America. In 2001, he received the BG Robert L. Denig Award for Distinguished Service presented by the U.S. Marine Corps Combat Correspondents Association. In 2005, he received the Abraham Lincoln Award of the Union League Club of Philadelphia, and the John Reagan (Tex) McCrary Award of the Congressional Medal of Honor Society.
Galloway was awarded the 2011 Doughboy Award, the highest honor the Army’s Infantry can bestow on an individual. Few civilians have ever received a Doughboy. On Veterans Day, 2011, he received the Legacy of Service Award of the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund.
Galloway is a member of the boards or advisory boards of the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund, the 1st Cavalry Division Association, the National Infantry Museum, the School of Social Studies of The Citadel in Charleston, S.C., the Museum of America’s Wars, and the Military Reporters and Editors Association.
Galloway is the recipient of honorary doctorate degrees from Norwich University and Mount St. Mary’s College of Newburgh, N.Y.
He now resides in Concord, N.C., with his wife, Dr. Grace Liem Galloway.
Customer reviews
- 5 star4 star3 star2 star1 star5 star82%15%3%0%0%82%
- 5 star4 star3 star2 star1 star4 star82%15%3%0%0%15%
- 5 star4 star3 star2 star1 star3 star82%15%3%0%0%3%
- 5 star4 star3 star2 star1 star2 star82%15%3%0%0%0%
- 5 star4 star3 star2 star1 star1 star82%15%3%0%0%0%
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on AmazonCustomers say
Customers find this book well-written and compelling, particularly praising its portrayal of brave soldiers. The narrative receives positive feedback for its pacing and leadership lessons, with one customer noting how it includes insights from former adversaries. Customers appreciate the heartfelt story, with one review highlighting its moving portrayal of friendships.
AI-generated from the text of customer reviews
Select to learn more
Customers find the book well written and interesting to read.
"...with Galloway have written a follow-up book which is just as good as the first book...." Read more
"...So good to hear the real stories and this one is a great finisher...." Read more
"...Although it was interesting reading, these chapters seemed out of place in the context of the first nine chapters - I was caught off guard by these..." Read more
"...Thank You General Moore. Excellent Book and Excellent Transaction. Highly Recommended!-1st Cav 2/19 FA Vet." Read more
Customers find the book's narrative compelling, describing it as an awesome story of brave men, with one customer noting how it covers the long aftermath of battle.
"...I'm just waiting for the book and movie on Ricky Rescorla. A life so extraordinary it couln't have been scripted better by Shakespeare...." Read more
"...The inspiring courage and tenacity of the leaders who fought there, I came to know as soon as I was old enough and is reflected in this great story..." Read more
"...Truly inspiring! I greatly enjoyed this book for the author's perspective on the human cost of war in general - and in this case,..." Read more
"LTG Moore and Joe Galloway have written the perfect sequel to "We Were Soldiers Once... and Young" and also brought closure to the Battle of the Ia..." Read more
Customers appreciate the pacing of the book, with individual reviews highlighting its excellent lessons on leadership, insights from former adversaries, behind-the-scenes look at thought processes, and detailed explanations of enemy motives and actions.
"...The healing powers of the years and the realization that the men on both sides were just doing their soldierly duties, made them realize that their..." Read more
"...Helps the healing for so many and great leadership lessons in this " the rest of the story"...." Read more
"...survive the war but are forever changed. I also enjoyed the description of Vietnam as it is now and the interaction that the returning..." Read more
"...up several times while reading "We Are Soldiers Still," the book was therapeutic...." Read more
Customers appreciate the leadership lessons in the book, describing it as great reference material that is succinctly stated and well-written.
"...I bought this book after listening to it for the great leadership reference material as well as the story...." Read more
"Just finished the book. Nice writing by Gen Hal Moore" Read more
"...His comments on management are unparalleled. He understands the principles of leadership and has demonstrated by life the essentials of a great..." Read more
"...Lessons not just in leadership, but I'm forgiveness, in love and friendship and loyalty...." Read more
Customers appreciate the heartfelt story of the book, describing it as emotional and moving, with one customer highlighting the poignant journey of General Moore and another noting how it brings back long-buried feelings.
"...to equate now with then; in my pleasure at feeling the noble warmth of Moore's humanity...." Read more
"...A very poignant journey for General Moore and journalist Joe Gallagher back to Vietnam and the Ia Drang valley where so many of Hal Moore's boys so..." Read more
"...he became totally opposed to the Vietnam War, plus the very moving story of the friendships that developed between the American and North Vietnamese..." Read more
"...written on the popularity of "We Were Soldiers" and does not give the feelings of those who went back enough weight, in my opinion...." Read more
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews. Please reload the page.
- Reviewed in the United States on June 13, 2009I need hardly add superlatives to the monumental epic that was "We were Soldiers Once..." I consider myself priveleged to have read and thereby shared the epic events described in the company of a humanitarian, reflective and yet ultimately humble hero, General Moore.
You rocket in on that chopper and the book gets it on from the get go.
Once you are through the X-Ray and Albany horrors don't expect a respite. I cried like a child as the fallout from the deaths of these brave men was spelled out by those they left behind.
I recommend that you then watch the Mel Gibson movie to compare your mind's eye picture of the battle with Hollywood's. Old Mel did a fine job. It was exactly how I had pictured it. Book followed by movie; usually such a move is a fraught exercise but this only enhanced my understanding.
The film does not address the subsequent Albany ambush and what appears to be a huge embarassment for the army. Failures all along the line led to a needless massacre. The army looked the other way in the aftermath. Moore does not shy away from the controversy in this second book and Westmoreland gets a lot of stick. (Nothing compared to Moore's later stinging rebuke of Dubya and Rumsfeld...may they burn in hell for the US lives they have so recklessly thrown away)
"We are Warriors Still" I found compulsory reading in order to complete my Ia Drang experience. I found it mesmerizing and heartbreaking. Moore and his comrades do the ultimate service to their dead buddies by flying to the now deserted battlesite and walking the lines on one last patrol.
I ate up the book barely pausing in my need to equate now with then; in my pleasure at feeling the noble warmth of Moore's humanity. Those troops could not have had a better commander in the field. A Rommel of a man!
That being said, I share my fellow reviewers' consternation at Moore's forgiveness and embrace of foes who callously murdered both US POWs and wounded in the field.
The NVA General An's comment that they were worried that the wounded soldiers would kill them if not silenced is simply not good enough. I know some of you out there will bring up Mai Lai but that was an exception. An seems to talk of this murder as an unfortunate but necessary policy. People have gone to the gallows or the Hague for less. Moore also mentions the massacres by the NVA of the civilians in Hue and on the road to Cambodia. We're talking in the tens of thousands here. Never heard Hanoi Jane bleating about that side of the conflict. Yet Moore incomprehensibly still finds it in his heart to see the NVA as patriots. I'm sure Stalin was one too but I'd still like to have put arsenic in his tea if I'd sat with him.
There's also a chapter on leadership which seems a little out of place in this book and seems more geared to military cadets reading the book as a designated text.
In closing, you simple cannot not read this if the first book hooked you in.
I'm just waiting for the book and movie on Ricky Rescorla. A life so extraordinary it couln't have been scripted better by Shakespeare.
General Moore, Joe Galloway I salute you.
- Reviewed in the United States on July 12, 2012"We Are Soldiers Still" is the continuation of the stories of the men of the 1st of the 7th and the 2nd of the 7th Cav and how they continued their lives after those fateful days in the Ia Drang Valley in November of 1965. This journey essentially will bring the hoped for closure of these combatants who still to this day carry the baggage of the actions they took and the horrors ever resultant of such combat.
General Moore and Joe Galloway take several trips back to Vietnam where they meet with their former enemies who included General Giap, General Man and General An who in fact was the commander of the forces who fought Galloway's unit in the battle of the Ia Drang Valley. After many attempts to visit the Ia Drang Valley, the Vietnamese government finally acquiesced and a small group of veterans along with Joe Galloway from the 1st of the 7th and 2nd of the 7th Cav spent a whole day and night at the sacred battle site. They walked the battlefield with their former enemies retelling old combat stories In fact with a little scheming General Moore got to spend the whole night at the battle site with his veteran friends and his journalistic buddy Joe Galloway
.
A great deal of thought and discussion through interpreters gave much light as to what really happened on those fateful days in the Valley. During this meaningful series of discussions a bond of professional respect and yes even friendship was realized. The healing powers of the years and the realization that the men on both sides were just doing their soldierly duties, made them realize that their enemies were human just like they were.
Later upon further persuasion General Moore and Joe Galloway visited the battlefield of Dien Bien Phu. General Giap further discussed why the Americans refused to learn the lessons of the mistakes the French made in the French-Indo China War. Frankly I do believe General Moore who was fully educated in the readings of Bernard Fall already knew the consequences of the actions taken by the USA. He knew all to well!!!
General Moore gives us his theories of leadership and yes he gives us a bird's eye view of what he thought of the war in Vietnam. No spoilers here, you have to read the book for that. But what I will say about these tenants of leadership and his take of the wars in Vietnam and Iraq are what I also firmly believe in. Moore along with Galloway have written a follow-up book which is just as good as the first book. In saying that, usually follow-up books are just a rehash, not here with this great read. Please read it, and see the basic and good principles which are indeed common sense and seem easy to do, but in actuality living these principles takes a great deal of discipline and no fear of failure.
- Reviewed in the United States on May 7, 2024Grew up watching the Vietnam conflict on the news every night since I was 5-6 years old until I was 14. So good to hear the real stories and this one is a great finisher. Helps the healing for so many and great leadership lessons in this " the rest of the story".I bought this book after listening to it for the great leadership reference material as well as the story. God bless the men and women who gave all and their families, in one of the biggest disasters in American history. The inspiring courage and tenacity of the leaders who fought there, I came to know as soon as I was old enough and is reflected in this great story and its prequel. Loved those men.
Top reviews from other countries
-
Jürgen SchnurrReviewed in Germany on November 21, 2015
5.0 out of 5 stars Fortsetzung, Hindergrundbericht und Vermächtnis
"We Are Soldier Still" ist ein vielschichtiges Werk. Das kürzeste, das mir dazu einfällt ist "absolut lesenswert". Alles andere erfordert sehr viel mehr Worte.
Wegen der vielen Erzählstränge ist dieses Buch nicht so leicht zugänglich wie "We Were Soldiers Once...and Young: Ia Drang - The Battle That Changed the War in Vietnam". An einigen Stellen musste ich aufpassen, dass ich mich nicht in den Zeitlinien verhedderte.
Geschichte zum Buch "We Were Soldiers Once ... and Young"
=========================================================
Moore and Galloway erzählen kurz wie sie sich für das Buch verabredet haben und wie es entstand. Und sehr ausführlich über ihre Treffen mit den verantwortlichen vietnamesischen Offizieren.
Ein weiteres Ziel ihres Vietnam-Besuchs, das Schlachtfeld nach 25 Jahren nochmals zu Besuchen, konnten sie vor Veröffentlichung des nicht erreichen. Auch weil die Vietnamesen sich nicht über die Ziele der Autoren im Klaren waren.
Bericht über Vietnamreisen amerikanischer Veteranen
===================================================
Reise nach Ia Drang
-------------------
Nachdem das Buch "We Were Soldiers Once ... and Young" erschienen war, haben es natürlich auch die vietnamesischen Offiziellen gelesen. Es hat Ihnen sehr gefallen und so haben sie den Wunsch der Autoren erfüllt, das Schlachtfeld zu besuchen.
Der Reisebericht ist sehr interessant, weil er einerseits die vietnamesischen Offiziere vorstellt und andererseits das aufeinandertreffen von Leuten beschreibt die 30 Jahre zuvor aufeinander geschoßen haben und Kameraden getötet oder verwundet haben.
So beschreibt das Buch die Geschichte einer Reise und auch wie die Reise die Reisenden einander näherbringt. Sie erkennen immer mehr, dass sie einiges gemeinsam haben. Der Titel des Buches "We are soldiers still" ist die Essenz dieser Reise. Sie sind immer noch Soldaten
Reise nach Dien Bien Phu
------------------------
Eine zweite Reise ging nach Dien Bien Phu. Anhand dieser Reise reflektiert Hal Moore Sinn und Unsinn des amerikanischen Vietnamkriegs. Beim ersten Zusammentreffen hatte General Giap gesagt, dass die Amerikaner, wenn sie die Schlacht bei Dien Bien Phu wirklich studiert hätten, sich nie auf den Krieg mit den Vietnamesen eingelassen hätte.
Dien Bien Phu war eine Schlacht bei der sich die Französische Armee selbst eine Falle stellte und sich hineinsetzte. Sie wollte die Vietnamesen zur Schlacht zwingen und wollten sie ausbluten. Das französische Oberkommando war davon überzeugt, dass sie mit ihrer Luftwaffe und der leichten Artillerie der Fallschirmjäger jeden Angriff der Vietnamesen zerschlagen konnten. Sie waren davon überzeugt, dass die Vietnamesen keine Artillerie zum Schlachtfeld bringen und effektiv einsetzen könnten. Die Vietnamesen schafften die Artillerie durch den Dschungel und setzen sie so effektiv ein, dass die Franzosen sie nicht ausschalten konnten. Die französischen Truppen verloren die Schlacht.
Dieser unbändige Wille sich den Fremden nicht zu beugen, die bedingungslose Opferbereitschaft der Truppen, ihre Kampfkraft und die Unterstützung der Bevölkerung hätten die Amerikaner warnen müssen, sich in diesen Krieg ziehen zu lassen.
Hal Moore ist überzeugt, dass dieser Krieg für die Amerikaner nicht zu gewinnen war.
Durch das Eingreifen haben die Amerikaner zwar die fragile südvietnamesische Regierung vordergründig gestützt. Aber das Auftreten der Amerikaner machten den Krieg damit noch mehr zu einem nationalen Krieg. Für einen nationalen Krieg sind die Vietnamesen bereit alles zu mobilisieren und große Opfer zu ertragen.
Aus meiner Sicht ist dies ein sehr wichtiger Aspekt. Aber einen anderen wichtigen Aspekt nennt Hal Moore und nennen auch die meisten anderen Autoren nicht. Ich habe 2005 Chu Chi besucht. In Chu Chi kann man Teile des Vietcong-Tunnelsystems besichtigen. Außer Tunneln, die für Touristen aufgeweitet wurden und verschiednen unterirdischen Räumen, gab es einen Film zu sehen. Während dieses Films wurde mir bewusst, dass ein wichtiger Faktor für den Zulauf des Vietcong die amerikanische Kriegsführung war. Sie war militärisch weitgehend ineffektiv aber gleichzeitig für die Bevölkerung verheerend. Die weitläufige Zerstörungen und die große Verluste unter der Zivilbevölkerung durch amerikanische Luftangriffe trieb einen immer größeren Keil zwischen die Bevölkerung und die südvietnamesische Regierung, die immer weiter an Rückhalt verlor.
Kurzbeschreibung der Rolle der Unteroffiziere
============================================
Das Kapitel "The Backbone of the Army" beschreibt wieso die Unteroffiziere so wichtig für die Army sind. Das hat zwei Aspekte:
- Unteroffiziere unterstützen mit ihrer Erfahrung die jungen unerfahrenen Offiziere die als Zugführer und Kompaniechefs dienen. Die Stelle als Second Lieutenant ist für einen amerikanischen Offizier der erste Kontakt mit der Truppe.
- Unteroffiziere bleiben länger in der Truppe. Durch ihre lange Zeit in einer Einheit sorgen sie für Kontinuität und drücken den Einheiten ihren Stempel auf. Die Offiziere hingegen sind meist nur kurz auf einem Kommando. Hinzu kommt dass Verwendungen als Truppenführer nur ein Teil ihrer Laufbahn ausmacht. Sie verbringen viel Zeit in Stabsstellen.
Als Beispiel wird die Laufbahn von Master Sergeant Basil L. Plumley kurz geschildert. Er hatte im 2. Weltkrieg 4 Kampfabsprünge, kämpfte im Koreakrieg und half Hal Moore das Bataillon durch die Schlacht in Ia Drang zu führen.
Kurze Bio über Harold Moore
===========================
Kurz und prägnant wird die Laufbahn von Hal Moore geschildert. Diese Kurzbio ist in den einzelnen Fragmenten des Buch hineingewoben. Die Schlacht von Ia Drang war für ihn das markanteste Erlebnis. Trotz seiner Teilnahme am Koreakrieg.
Testament eines alten Soldaten
==============================
Das Buch ist im Jahr 2008 erschienen.
Als alter Soldat schreibt Hal Moore über den Krieg im allgemeinen und auch über den zweiten Irakkrieg im Besonderen. Seine Ausführungen zum Irakkrieg gipfeln in folgendem Satz: "In Bezug auf Minister Rumsfeld, ich hatte nicht erwartet, dass ich lange genug leben würde, um einen Chef im Pentagon zu erleben, gegen den der Minister der Vietnamkriesgszeit Robert McNamara gut aussieht."
Außerdem schreibt Hal Moore darüber, was er über die Führung von Menschen denkt. Diese 10 Seiten sind sehr lesenswert. Sie treffen den Kern, wo viele Managementbücher Blödsinn verbreiten.
Gedenken an gestorbene Menschen
===============================
Hier wird kurz die Lebensgeschichte von zwei Personen geschildert die Hal Moore nahestanden.
Cyril R. Rescorla hat Hal Moore sehr beeindruckt. Er war Engländer und diente freiwillig in der US-Army. Er hat in der Schlacht in Ia Drang an beiden Phasen teilgenommen. Durch seine gute Führung erlitt sein Zug, obwohl er im heftige Gefechte verwickelt war, nur kleine Verluste. 1966 schied er aus der US Army aus und arbeitete bis zum 11. September 2001 als Sicherheitsberater.
Julie Moore ware eine Soldatentochter und da sie Hal Moore heratete wurde sie eine Soldatenfrau. Und da zwei ihrer Söhne zur Army gingen, war sie auch Soldatenmutter. Somit war ihr Leben von der Army geprägt.
Fazit
=====
Am Besten beschreibt man dieses Buch eine Collage von Fragmenten. Sie sind nicht entlang einer Zeitlinie angeordnet und manchmal ist man kurz verwirrt, wann sich das beschriebene abspielt. Aber der nüchterne und sachliche Stil macht es sehr lesenswert.
Wem "We Were Soldiers Once...and Young: Ia Drang - The Battle That Changed the War in Vietnam" gefallen hat, wird auch dieses Buch gerne lesen. Wer "We Were Soldiers Once...and Young: Ia Drang - The Battle That Changed the War in Vietnam" noch nicht kennt, dem empfehle ich, zuerst dieses Buch zu lesen. Denn ohne diese Vorgeschichte kann man die Ausführungen von "We Are Soldiers Still" nicht verstehen.
- sue youngReviewed in Australia on February 4, 2016
4.0 out of 5 stars A great memoir for Old soldiers who can sadly be forgotten ...
A great memoir for Old soldiers who can sadly be forgotten as time marches on. I was living in Darwin, Australia at the time of the battle and we could hear parts of the battle on HF radio. It was very static affected but you knew things were very hot from the urgent note in the radio ops and commanders voices.
- H. OsbornReviewed in Canada on May 8, 2014
5.0 out of 5 stars Very good
Excellent read.
Excellent delivery and packaging.
A great followup to we were soldiers and young.
I recommend this to all interested in the landing and recall.
- Huckleberry FinnReviewed in the United Kingdom on August 29, 2012
5.0 out of 5 stars We Are Soldiers Still - Good Book
Just finished reading the second book about the Vietnam battles at La Drang and must say it was an interesting conclusion. Well worth the 4 hours it took to read it from cover to cover.
- graaham wrightReviewed in the United Kingdom on March 24, 2013
5.0 out of 5 stars One not to be missed
Having read WE WERE SOLDIERS AND YOUNG this book is almost a sequel. It is a brilliant read and shows how once bitter enemies can become friends. It is a must read for anyone who has read the original book.